Publised on 14/01/2020 by Richard. Last Updated on 10/09/2023 by Richard.
Deliciously cheesy vegan twice baked potatoes which are crispy and caramelised on the outside but soft, buttery and fluffy inside!
On all levels, including spiritual, these vegan twice baked potatoes are an awakening. As anybody who's anybody knows, this blog is fuelled almost entirely by a deep, primal understanding of the bond between human and spud. Potatoes, in all forms, are celebrated here. But this recipe, I must declare, is something else.
This particular incarnation of the potato is remarkable for three main reasons which I shall outline below:
1. It's deceptively easy to make.
2. It's undeniably delicious.
3. It's entirely vegan.
How do I make Vegan Twice Baked Potatoes?
This is the sort of recipe you'll want to keep for impressing people. It's not difficult, and yeah, it takes some time. But have you ever compared a microwaved potato to an oven baked one??
Different 👏 Damn 👏 Ball 👏 Park 👏
The full instructions and ingredients, as always, are at the bottom of the page, but here are some pointers on how to nail this recipe.
1. Pick the right potato!
Ok, not actually a step in the cooking process, but SUPER important!
Not just any old spud will do! The aim here is to make sure we end up with a crispy, caramelised skin and a fluffy, buttery inside. Therefore, you want to avoid any waxy varieties of potato (Maris Peer, Charlotte, Jersey royals) and stick with floury varieties like Maris Piper, King Edward and Ailsa. If you're not sure which variety you're looking at, just ask your local greengrocer.
2. Bake your potatoes
Yep, when I say twice baked, I really mean it. Before we can do ANYTHING we need to make sure our spuds are baked. I like to do mine in a baking tray, pricked all over with a fork.
My mum does hers on a metal skewer, which helps the insides cook faster, but I avoid that for this recipe because it can make slicing and scooping a little trickier later on.
3. Make the "cheese"
Did I mention that these bad boys are AS CHEESY AS ALL HELL?? And yes, they're vegan, don't come for me! This process is very similar to my Vegan Mozzarella recipe but we're going to use potato starch instead of tapioca starch, just to keep that whole potato vibe going strong!
Blend up all your ingredients and cook, whisking constantly, until mega thick and stretchy!
4. Slice n scoop!
Once baked, you want to slice off a third of the potato, lengthways. Unless you're a master at the game hot-potato, you'll want to leave them to cool for about 10 mins before you handle them.
Use a sharp knife and slice lengthways to remove about a third of the spud. Using a spoon, scoop out the 'flesh' from the little third and pop it into a bowl. Repeat with all of the potatoes.
5. Prepare the filling
Using the potato flesh which you've scooped out, we're going to make a deliciously cheesy filling for the potatoes.
First you need to mash the potato you scooped into the bowl with some vegan butter and milk. Next you're going to add half of the 'cheese' mixture from the saucepan and mix until well combined. Hey presto - a mega cheesy filling! Time to top your potatoes!
6. Bake AGAIN!
Once your potatoes are topped with the extra filling, I like to add a little more of the vegan cheese we whipped up. It helps everything to stay super melty and cheesy. Finish with a pinch of salt, some more vegan butter and a grind of black pepper.
Pop your potatoes back into the oven for a second bake. Once done, I like to give mine a final blast under the grill to make sure they're crazy crispy and caramelised. Bingo! The end! Put them in your face!
Any special ingredients?
There's nothing too crazy in this recipe - mostly a load of pantry ingredients. But here are two dudes you simply must have in order to make this recipe.
This is the magic ingredient to getting a melty, stretchy cheesy texture to your potato filling. You can also use tapioca starch with similar results.
Nutritional Yeast
Everyone's favourite hippy powder! It tastes like a really nice, mellow, nutty cheese and when combined with something acidic (apple cider vinegar in this case) you get some seriously cheesy vibes!
Grab some nutritional yeast!
What should I serve vegan twice baked potatoes with?
I like to serve these as part of a roast dinner, perhaps in place of (or even WITH) roast potatoes. Why not try serving with:
- Perfect Vegan Gravy
- Vegan Shepherd's Pie
- Roasted Brussels Sprouts
Vegan Twice Baked Potatoes
Ingredients
- 5 baking potatoes ((thoroughly washed but not peeled))
- 350 ml plant milk
- 50 g coconut oil ((deoderised or "refined"))
- 3 tablespoon nutritional yeast
- ½ teaspoon onion powder
- ½ teaspoon garlic powder
- 1½ teaspoon fine sea salt
- 4 tablespoon potato starch
- 2 tablespoon vegan butter
- 3 tablespoon plant milk
- pinch ground black pepper
- pinch flaky sea salt
- small bunch fresh parsley
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 170c.
- Using a fork, prick the potatoes all over a few times. Place on a baking tray and put in the oven for a total of one hour, removing half-way to flip.
- While the potatoes bake, make the "cheese" for the filling. Place the 350ml of plant milk, coconut oil, nutritional yeast, onion powder, garlic powder, fine sea salt, and potato starch in the cup of a high-speed blender. Blend until smooth.
- Transfer to a medium saucepan and place over medium-low heat. Whisking constantly, cook until the mixture is very thick and stretchy. Remove from the heat.
- Once the potatoes have baked for an hour, remove from the oven and leave to cool for 10 minutes. Hold one potato with a napkin. Working lengthways, slice off a third of each potato.
- Using a spoon and working only with the sliced off ⅓, scoop out the potato to separate from the skin. Transfer all the scooped out potato to a bowl.
- Using a masher or a fork, combine the scooped out potato with the vegan butter and plant milk. Mash well until smooth before adding around half of the "cheese" mixture. Mash well until fully incorporated.
- Divide the cheesy mashed potato mixture between the five baked potatoes, packing the filling on top and making sure it's rough and domed rather than smoothly and flat.
- Using a teaspoon, top each potato with a little of the remaining "cheese". It's best to use sparingly and I don't advise you use everything that's left in the saucepan. Top the potatoes with the black pepper and flaky sea salt (and a little knob of vegan butter if you have any spare) then return to the oven for a further 20 minutes.
- After 20 minutes the potatoes should look crispy on the sides and bubbly on top. Switch the oven to grill/broil and place the potatoes nice and close to the heat element. Grill/broil the potatoes until they're golden brown and crispy on top (around 3-5 minutes) but watch them like a hawk as they'll burn easily at this stage.
- Remove from the oven and sprinkle with some finely chopped parsley before serving.
Paige
I’m a potato fiend so super Excited to try this recipe...my question is when making the mozzarella (as I made it for pizzas in the past) i tried your recipe in the past so I got the agar powder and psyllium husks for the stretchy affect, is this a different mozza recipe with the same great taste?
Didi
Yep. Where is the vinegar used????
Sheila
Where is the apple cider vinegar you mention ? My daughter will not use nutritional yeast because, as she says, it does not taste like cheese. I thought you had discovered some game-changing secret using apple cider vinegar and am disappointed that you haven’t shared it with us !
Sheila
Where is the apple cider vinegar you mention ? My daughter will not use nutritional yeast because, as she says, it does not taste like cheese. I thought you had discovered some game-changing secret using apple cider vinegar and am disappointed that you haven’t shared it with us !
holly
I think the 170 degrees was a mistake... found this out the hard way, thankfully I realized this half way only. 425 is the correct answer.
Richard Makin
I’m confused - were you cooking in Celsius or Fahrenheit? The oven temperature I gave was correct and in Celsius so it seems like you’ve made a mistake and then given me a two star review for it.
holly
I think the 170 degrees was a mistake... found this out the hard way, thankfully I realized this half way only. 425 is the correct answer.
Richard Makin
I’m confused - were you cooking in Celsius or Fahrenheit? The oven temperature I gave was correct and in Celsius so it seems like you’ve made a mistake and then given me a two star review for it.
Sam Kear
These were out of this world good! Never would have thought to add more potato starch to potatoes but it turned out awesome! We topped ours with some vegan sour cream and coconut bacon.
Richard Makin
That's amazing news mate! Thanks for the 5 stars too! Big love!
Sam Kear
These were out of this world good! Never would have thought to add more potato starch to potatoes but it turned out awesome! We topped ours with some vegan sour cream and coconut bacon.
Richard Makin
That's amazing news mate! Thanks for the 5 stars too! Big love!
Alexia
Can this be made ahead? I'm looking to make ahead and freeze them, but not sure about the texture, if it changes or not during the freezing process.
Homeschool Mom
As for the apple cider vinegar that was mentioned, but then not addressed, I referenced a recipe that makes a cashew faux cheese sauce that we love. It used equal amounts of nutritional yeast compared to apple cider vinegar and lemon. Since it was cashew-based and this one isn't, I erred on the side of caution and after blending and tasting this cheese sauce (before cooking it), I added 1/2 Tablespoon apple cider vinegar to this recipe. It did improve the "cheese" taste. I could've possibly added even more, but I didn't want to risk overdoing it.
That aside, I must've used the wrong potatoes (just had reds here, which are less starchy), because my filling was too runny to mound up. I had reduced the vegan butter by half. I wound up scooping the potatoes into hollow boats so I could fill them up. I did use a big scoop of the cheese on top of them, using up what I had left over, because I appreciated that taste. I wish there were more detail on how long to cook up the cheese sauce. I cooked until it was thick and sticky, but it still wasn't able to be "mounded" on top of the finished potatoes. When baking some of the ones I tried to "mound" had their toppings slide off to the side and bake onto the pan. In our family of 5, these had mixed reviews from one person taking thirds to another person not enjoying their first helping (texture/appearance).
I am SO thankful for people who take time to make their own vegan cheese at home and post the recipes! Please don't view my sharing my experience as a criticism as I recognize I failed to get the right potatoes. As a busy mom with allergy-kids, even recipes like this that don't hit it out of the park are still a very appreciated change from the normal routine and provide a baseline for future recipe experiments. I liked the cheese sauce enough to try making it again and cooking it even longer to see if it thickens more.
Clare Curtis
Thank you so much for this awesome recipe! I ended up scooping out all of the potatoes and putting all of the cheezy mixture in, it was just like the steakhouse twice baked potatoes I remember having before becoming vegan. The flavor is just so lovely.